Petitionary prayer is basically a prayer in which you ask god for something. In fact, we probably think that such prayer is a far cry from the ecstasy of a st teresa of avila or the mystical union achieved in contemplation by a st john of the cross. For ease of discussion, let us say that the target of a petitionary prayer is the token event or events prayed for, and that a petitionary prayer is answered only if the target of the prayer. God, causality, and petitionary prayer forthcoming in faith and philosophy. Historically, the most interesting philosophical puzzles concerning petitionary prayer have arisen in connection with the traditional monotheism shared by judaism, christianity, and islam. Pdf philosophical reflection on petitionary prayer researchgate. His other writings on petitionary prayer appear in the stanford encyclopedia of philosophy, the oxford handbook of philosophical theology, and the european journal for philosophy of religion. The argument that follows, and my investigation of it, works just a. God chooses to respond to the world in certain ways, and our prayers are part of the world to which he responds. Though it explains the role of faith, i find it difficult to shake the standard way of thinking about petitionary prayer, whereby we ask god to solely accomplish various things. Davison and i connected back in may of last year at a conference here in grand rapids a science and religion dialogue for which he was the keynote speaker. Pdf philosophical reflection on petitionary prayer.
Look, perhaps you want to say that the existence and role of petitionary prayer makes the world a better place, and thats why god included it in his creation. A philosophical investigation is a mindbending and deeply intelligent investigation into the nuances of the wellknown practice of petitionary prayer. Petitionary prayer, reasons, value theory, collective action, ecclesiology. Petitionary prayer can cause god to actualize a material state of af.
Davison looks at petitionary prayer through a diamond and sees facets of petitionary prayer and asks questions that are seldom asked. Petitionary prayer a philosophical investigation scott a. I attack his contrastive reasons account of what it takes for a request to be answered and provide an alternative account on which a request is answered as long as it has deliberative weight for the person asked. George santayana and the problem of petitionary prayer.
Home philosophy of religion articles petitionary prayer prayer. Robin collinss cocreational model of petitionary prayer. Petitionary prayer stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. This element is a critical overview of the manner in which the concept of miracle is understood and discussed in contemporary analytic philosophy of religion. Well, presumably, it is for god to bear a certain relation the being present at relation to every place. North american philosophical publications petitionary prayer authors.
Jesus told his disciples, whatever you ask for in prayer, believe that you have received it, and it will be yours mk. Theists have always recognized various logical and moral limits to divine action in the world, but do these limits leave any space among gods reasons for. Public users are able to search the site and view the abstracts and keywords for each book and chapter without a subscription. After years of comparative neglect, a renewed research interest developed in the field of prayer during the mid1980s and has led to prayer being recognized as of central importance in understanding the role of religion and spirituality in human development and human functioning. According to a recent newsweek survey 87% of americans said that they believe that god answers. Longawaited medical study questions the power of prayer. Basic philosophical issues inform the question as to whether prayer is efficacious, for example, whether statistical inference and falsifiability inform what it means to prove or disprove something, and the problem of demarcation, i.
Philosophical reflection on petitionary prayer smith 20. And, even though this is a work of analytic philosophy, it must be said in praise of davisons approach that it is not an attempt to colonise the. Finley, kate 2019 scott davison, petitionary prayer. Aug 15, 2012 the focus of this article is petitionary prayer, in which a petitioner requests something. Assuming that the god of traditional theism exists, is it reasonable to think that god answers specific petitionary prayers. Communication with god or for some traditions other supernatural beings and departed spirits.
Murray franklin and marshall college published in contemporary debates in the philosophy of religion, michael peterson editor, blackwell publishers, 2005 the belief that god responds to prayer is widespread. A philosophical investigation pdf download full pdf read. Jul 10, 2006 first, our prayers may sometimes not be granted because of our lack of faith. But if so, it would appear that petitionary prayer is pointless. All three maintain that petitionary prayer should be seen as a divinely instituted way of causing things. God, causality, and petitionary prayer forthcoming in faith. I say this because god would be omniscient and would already be aware of our needs. University of illinois press on behalf of the north american philosophical publications.
Historically, most traditional theists have believed that god sometimes answers prayers for. Either doing something is the best god can do or it is not. God, causality, and petitionary prayer forthcoming in faith and philosophy 7 omnipotence as the ability to do anything which it is not logically impossible for him to do, but it does not make all the relevant implications of this definition explicit. Religion survey, for example, 84% of all americans pray on at least some. Considers whether, if the god of traditional theism were to exist, it would be reasonable to think this god would answer prayers. Kirjapaino tarmo, 1973, cited in capps, psychology of petitionary prayer, 6. A philosophical investigation develops a new account of the conditions required for a petitionary prayer to be answered by employing the. The efficacy of prayer has been the topic of various studies since at least 1872.
This volume explores the philosophical issues involved in the idea of petitionary prayer, where this is conceived as an activity designed to influence the action of the allknowing, allpowerful, perfectly good god of traditional theism. The focus of this article is petitionary prayer, in which a petitioner requests something. He and cohoe, god, causality, and petitionary prayer, are in the minority who disagree. For ease of discussion, let us say that the target of a petitionary prayer is the token event or events prayed for, and that a petitionary prayer is answered only if the target of the prayer occurs. While some religious groups argue that the power of prayer is.
These studies on intercessory prayer have revealed no objective effect. Scott davison is professor of philosophy at morehead state university. Petitionary prayer is what the apostle paul enjoins christians to do in philippians 4. In its most basic sense, a miracle is an unusual, unexpected, observable event brought about by direct divine intervention. They also believe that god created the world, sustains it in being from moment to moment, and providentially guides all events, in accordance with a plan, towards a good ending. I really enjoyed his analysis and had to have him on the show. William james, the varieties of religious experience new york. With careful attention to recent developments in metaphysics, epistemology, and value theory, scott a. Dec 23, 20 1 therefore examines two different types of petitionary prayer.
A philosophical investigation, poses this type of question as follows. There are many forms of prayer, including propitiation, adoration and thanksgiving, but most philosophical discussions of prayer have focused on the problems posed by petitionary prayer, in which a person makes a request to god for. In part because of cases like this, davison rejects a counterfactual dependence account of answered prayer where a prayer is answered when it is true that had the petitioner not offered the prayer, god would not have provided the object of the prayer 2728. Recently the new york times ran a story with an intriguing title. Maybe gods chief purpose of petitionary prayer is to actually reveal things to the person praying to give them insight or ideas about what they should do, or how to handle a certain situation.
But what is it, exactly, for god to manifest ubiquitous presence. This article focuses on the being present at relation which figures so prominently in the. Caleb cohoe metropolitan state university of denver. However, it is imperative to realize that petitionary prayer is in fact the most basic and, as the most basic, an utterly necessary form of prayer. The value and necessity of petitionary prayer todays. Caleb cohoe metropolitan state university of denver abstract. Traditional theists believe that there exists an allknowing, allpowerful, perfectly loving, and perfectly good god. The value and necessity of petitionary prayer today. This book explores the philosophical issues involved in the idea of petitionary prayer, where this is conceived as an activity designed to influence the action of.
Philosophy of religion and petitionary prayer teaching documents boethius consolation annotations. Petitionary prayer appears pointless in light of divine attributes like. Davison surveys the contemporary literature on this. Davison surveys the contemporary literature on this question. European journal for philosophy of religion 10, no. Investigation1, scott davison explores the landscape of the contemporary debate on this question within analytic. See especially davison petitionary prayer 2009, 287288 for discussion. And patients who knew they were being prayed for had a higher rate of post.
I attack his contrastive reasons account of what it takes for a request to be answered and provide an alternative. How puzzles of petitionary prayer solve themselves eplace. Problems and promises of petitionary prayer probe ministries. This book is, as its subtitle advertises, a philosophical investigation. When were grateful for some blessing, we may offer up a prayer of thanksgiving. A philosophical investigation addresses the following question. I argue that petitionary prayer is useless is because of how it interacts with free will.
When weve done something wrong, we may unburden our conscience by confessing our sin to god. The presentation was on his recently released a book titled petitionary prayer. In this way, petitionary prayer would have a valuable function outside of just influencing god to take action. Second, despite experimental evidence that prayer increases commitment fincham et al. Access to the complete content on oxford handbooks online requires a subscription or purchase. A collaborative model of petitionary prayer gianluca di muzio department of history, philosophy, political science, and religious studies, indiana university northwest, 3400 broadway, gary, in 46408, usa email. European jour 16 nal for philosophy of religion, 3, 22737. Review david diquattro 2018 international journal for philosophy. To simplify matters, call this presupposed claim ppm, which we can restate in the following way. Article contributed by probe ministries visit probes website. A philosophical investigation develops a new account of the conditions required for a petitionary prayer to be answered by employing the notion of contrastive explanation. Published in contemporary debates in the philosophy of religion, michael peterson.
The argument we can generalize this puzzle, the puzzle of petitionary prayer, and express it in the form of an argument as follows. This article discusses several problems related to the concept of the traditional theistic gods answering petitionary prayers. The article examines the answers to this question given by three christian thinkers. Caleb murray cohoe, how could prayer make a difference.
Davison offers a contrastive reason account of answered. This book explores the philosophical issues involved in the idea of petitionary prayer, where this is conceived as an activity designed to influence the action of the allknowing, allpowerful, perfectly good god of traditional theism. They di er widely, however, on how prayer s e cacy is related to gods overall plan for the world. This verse makes it clear that the lord expects our prayers to be joined with faith in his ability to grant them. It seems to make no sense as it can be hard to see how human prayers could affect what god does. In fact, i find myself spontaneously praying for many things that seem to require gods sole causal activity e. Some are also metaphysical in nature, for instance those drawing on gods knowledge of the future, and some epistemological, for instance questioning whether we could ever know a. If it is the best god can do, then your asking wont make any difference to whether he does. Jan 02, 2018 protest as he might, it seems to me that the value of such a work is to give us clarity as to the practical implications of petitionary prayer and other sorts of communication with the divine.
Stephen l brock pontifical university of the holy cross. The focus of this article is petitionary prayer, in which a petitioner. God, causality, and petitionary prayer forthcoming in. In keeping with the literature on this subject, these prayers are referred to as petitionary prayers. God, causality, and petitionary prayer forthcoming in faith and philosophy 3 religion survey, for example, 84% of all americans pray on at least some occasions and 27% pray multiple times a day. Other issues i intend to avoid include peter geachs worries about prayer for events in. Petitionary prayer is what the apostle paul enjoins christians to do in phili. According to the tradition of western theism, god is said to enjoy the attribute of being everywhere present. This argument gives us philosophical reasons to doubt whether petitionary prayer. Considers whether, if the god of traditional theism were to exist, it would be reasonable to. Protest as he might, it seems to me that the value of such a work is to give us clarity as to the practical implications of petitionary prayer and other sorts of communication with the divine. Review david diquattro 2018 international journal for philosophy of religion 83 3. Historically, most traditional theists have believed that god sometimes answers prayers for particular things.
42 1452 1820 1728 509 643 106 533 29 1448 1399 145 384 49 186 1545 1089 762 1861 944 1527 1587 1644 710 849 1266 1574 945 129