Lecture 3 theories of accident causation traffic collision. Theories of causation there are a number of accident causation theories. The development of theories and modeling of accident causation is a dynamic field with the result that there is often a gap between the theoretical discussion and practice. The development of theories and modeling of accident causation is a dynamic field with. This domino theory was used by the us administration to justify the need for american intervention in various parts of the world. This paper therefore aims to discuss the theoretical underpinnings of reasons model.
Human and organisational factors in major accident prevention. This document focuses on a core element of this studywhich provides a succinct examination of the body of academic work on the subject of hof in major accident causation and prevention. Accidents, events that injure people, damage property and equipment don t just happen. Pdf major theories of construction accident causation. Aims although a popular framework for adverse event analyses, little formal guidance exists on the use of reasons accident causation model and its clinical application. Catastrophic accidents in conscientious companies david r. However, contemporary ohs professional practice requires at. There are several domino theories of accident causation. That is, a one to one relationship between an exposure and a. Perhaps the most popular systems theory on accident causation is james reasons swiss cheese model, originally proposed in 1990. Several models of accident causation exist in road accident research. The human factors theory of accident causation holds that a chain of events that is or was caused by consistent human error lead to an accident. Comparativestudyofhfacsandthe24modelaccidentcausationmodels.
Application of an improved model for accident analysis. Theories of causation conceptual schemes scientific theory demonology trephining classical theory freewill approach neoclassical approach rationalchoice theory postclassical theory deterrence theory routineactivities theory positivist school of criminology biological theories atavists anomalies phrenology somatotypes xyy chromosome biosocial. Multiple causation theory of accidents personal decision beliefs to work unsafely unsafe conditions human accidents errors traps injury systems unsafe acts andor failures loss overload root contributing immediate causes causes causes by dan hartshorn senior loss control consultant retired m. Heinrich, a safety engineer and pioneer in the field of industrial accident safety. The domino theory holds that accidents are not random acts of fate that just happen out of the blue. In the wider study, this analysis provided the foundation on which subsequent work was based, namely. Theories of accident causation cleveland state university. Heinrichs domino model of accident causation risk engineering.
Paoletta, csp, chmm does a low ori really mean your company is safe. This postulate embodies the idea of specificity of a cause. Many of these are common sense, as they are often used practices. Ajor theories of construction accident causation models. This article attempts to deliver explanation s of why accidents occur by analyzing the fundamental and developmental predecessors to accidental events. The objective of this report is to make an inventory of these models and to identify their basis of formulation. The human factors theory of accident causation attributes accidents to a chain of events ultimately caused by human error.
Each accident causation model theory engenders its own distinct approach. Domino theory of accident causation after studying 75,000 industrial accidents, herbert w. Injuries caused by the action of preceding factors. With such a diversity of theories, it will not be difficult to understand that there does not exist one single theory that is considered right or correct and is universally accepted. Henrich further contributed to the basic understanding of accident causation by developing the widely known domino theory. Systems model of construction accident causation management. An accident theory that ties safety and productivity together. Jul 01, 1976 because of this, an individual was more likely to initiate a hazardous incident in the accident phenomenon. Later theories included the structure of accidents model. Sep 04, 2014 there are several domino theories of accident causation.
Human error and accident causation theories, frameworks and. Theories of causation there are a number of accident causation theories, which hinze 1997 refers to, that. Heinrichs study laid the foundation for his axioms of industrial safety, and his now outdated domino theory of accident causation some of todays more. Construction accidents per employees in hong kong tang and poon, 1988. Factors from two or more models might be part of the cause. Reyes 1 f work accident n an unplanned or unexpected occurrence that may or may not result in personal injury, property damage, work stoppage or interference or any combination thereof which arises out of and in the course of employment. Disease transmitted by miasmas or clouds clinging to earths surface. This theory explains the accident process in terms of five factors.
The accident causation chain can be classified as the classical, modern, and contemporary accident causation chain according to the depth of analysis fu 20. Reyes 1 work accident n an unplanned or unexpected occurrence that may or may not result in personal injury, property damage, work stoppage or interference or any combination thereof which arises out of. Accident theories theories of accident causation there are several major theories concerning accident causation, each of which has some explanatory and predictive value. The domino theory developed in 1931 suggests that one event leads to another, then to another and so on, culminating in an accident. Alma maria jennifer gutierrez slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Since there are several existing models of accident causation, a first task is to make an inventory of these models and to identify their basis of formulation. Heinrich in the 1950 edition of his book industrial accident prevention. This theory uses the an alogy of 5 dominos standing up of the thin base side and when one falls it will push the other down. Note that domino theory presents a simplified model, which considers only one cause of an accident. Accident causation the most widely known theories of accident causation are. Heinrichs influential domino theory of accident causation is then proposed. It found that 88 percent of accidents are caused by unsafe acts of people, 10 percent by unsafe actions and 2 percent by acts of god. On the contrary the weakness of these theories is that they do not offer extensive strategic guidelines for managers and supervisors for reducing. Also, in the heinrich model, the focus is on immediate rather than root causes.
The intention of this paper is to enhance the overall understanding of the accident causation theories which signifies the identification of how hazards in the. Health and safety for quarrying undergraduates hse. Pdf accident causation theories shekina calizo academia. According to this theory, every step in a process has. Accidents on sites also lower staff morale, induce negative corporate image and lead to extension of time in project because of work rearrangements li, 2006. Mar 15, 2010 theories of accident causation reference. Doc multiple causation theory of accidents dan hartshorn. Theories of construction accidents causation heinrich domino theory of accident causationheinrich was the pioneer in the accident causation theories. At present, theories of accident causation are conceptual in nature and, as such, are of limited use in preventing and controlling accidents. This theory purports that multiple factors combine in random fashion any given order and come together at the intersection point to produce an accident. While each domino theory presents a different explanation for the cause of accidents, they all have one thing in common. Lecture 3 theories of accident causation free download as powerpoint presentation. Psychology we are too much accustomed to attribute to a single cause that which is the product.
Review of literature on construction accidents revealed that a copious number of theories have been propounded over the years by different theorists, though some. The systems theory of accident causation views any situation in which an accident might occur as a system with three components. This paper aims at studying and analyzing the evolution in accident causation models. The accident triangle, also known as heinrichs triangle or birds triangle, is a theory of industrial accident prevention.
While each domino theory presents a different explanation for the cause of accidents, they all have one. The swiss cheese model of accident causation is a model used in risk analysis and risk management, including aviation safety, engineering, healthcare, emergency service organizations, and as the principle behind layered security, as used in computer security and defense in depth. Models of causation health determinants april, 2012 1 introduction the safety aspects of occupational health and safety ohs, concerned with prevention of accident related injuries, are often seen as central to the role of the generalist ohs professional. Many accident analysis methods and accident models have been proposed. An accident theory that ties safety and productivity. The domino model of accident causation, as depicted by h.
The domino theory one of the more colorful theories of accident causation was formulated by heinrich 1959 and is known as the domino theory. Most important postulate is that the microorganism must always be found with the disease. After all, there is nothing more practical than a good theory, as s aid by john dewey best and kahn, 2006. Unsafe acts are made more likely by local conditions in the workplace. There are several major theories concerning accident causation, each of which has some explanatory and predictive value. Accident causation chains this becomes more apparent when theoretical models of accident causation are examined see cooper 2001b for a detailed overview. Removal of the central factor negates the action of the preceding factor. Comparativestudyofhfacsandthe24modelaccidentcausationmodel. Fundamental questions remain about the practical value and generalizability of accident causation frameworks for explaining construction accidents. Both models are highly reactive and cannot be used to predict the likelihood of accidents. Accident causation models report dacota wp5 d5 9 vf.
The evolution of construction accident causation models. The paper explores accident causation in the context of management philosophy and support for the safety professional. Construction industry is recognized and best described as an accident prone industry, being characterized with a plethora of occupational risks. Jan 01, 2015 perhaps the most popular systems theory on accident causation is james reasons swiss cheese model, originally proposed in 1990. Human error and accident causation theories, frameworks. An important hypothesis put forth is that unsafe acts are the reason most accidents. Pdf the theories of accident causation researchgate. Domino theory human factors theory accident incident theory epidemiological theory systems theory combination theory behavioral theory cee 698 construction health and safety chapter 3 domino theory herbert w. They are not random acts of fate that occur out of the blue.
Theory accident osha traffic collision occupational. The triangle was first proposed by herbert william. Theories of accident causation the most widely known theories of accident. However, contemporary ohs professional practice requires at least an equal.
According to heinrichs domino theory, unsafe acts and unsafe. It shows a relationship between serious accidents, minor accidents and near misses and proposes that if the number of minor accidents is reduced then there will be a corresponding fall in the number of serious accidents. The analysis uses the stamp systemstheoretic accident model and processes model that was presented at the mit internal symposium in may 2002 9. According to this theory, every step in a process has the potential for failure. Heinrich of travelers insurance concluded in the 1920s, that 88% of industrial accidents are caused by unsafe acts committed by fellow workers. The combination theory of accident causation posits that no one model theory can explain all accidents. The accident causation theory consists of the accident causation chain, accident attribution theory, and accident triangle theory fu et al. Human factors theory and methods dr paul salmon ms amy williamson ms eve mitsopoulosrubens dr christina rudinbrown dr michael lenne human factors group, monash university accident research centre. One example of a multiple causation theory is the 4 ms which stand for. The claimant in village did not have a specific incident, but woke up with a sore back following several days of moving boxes. He described the accidents causation theory, man and machine relationship, frequency and severity relation, unsafe acts reasons, management role in accident prevention, costs of accidents and the. An underlying theme is that managements thoughts and actions influence work conditions and worker behavior. The intention of this paper is to enhance the overall understanding of the accident causation theories which signifies the identification of how hazards in the construction workplaces cause losses.
142 451 525 564 311 431 75 190 114 1457 337 1104 1823 20 1805 1130 95 383 1128 256 632 399 124 644 377 92 288 909 1299 620 1640 1513 727 1534 530